Cape May Court House, located in the heart of Cape May County, New Jersey, is a charming town that offers more than just picturesque streets and historical landmarks. The town is home to some of the best food destinations in the region, from cozy cafés to upscale dining establishments. Whether you’re a local resident or just visiting, there’s no shortage of delicious spots to explore in Cape May Court House. Here’s a guide to some of the best food restaurants in the area, perfect for any occasion and palate.
1. The Blue Pig Tavern
Located in the heart of the historic Congress Hall, The Blue Pig Tavern is a beloved restaurant that offers a welcoming atmosphere and a menu filled with local flavors. Known for its comfort food with a modern twist, this tavern is perfect for those looking for a laid-back yet satisfying meal.
Must Try: The Tavern Burger, a delicious, juicy burger made with local beef, and their signature seafood dishes like the crab cakes. Pair it with one of their local craft beers for a true Cape May experience.
Why Visit: With a cozy interior and beautiful outdoor seating options, it’s an ideal spot for a relaxing breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Their commitment to using fresh, local ingredients sets them apart in the Cape May food scene.
2. 410 Bank Street Restaurant
For a fine dining experience in Cape May Court House, 410 Bank Street Restaurant offers an intimate, upscale atmosphere with a focus on contemporary American cuisine. Known for its sophisticated setting and impeccable service, this restaurant is perfect for a special occasion or a night out.
Must Try: The Seared Scallops or the Duck Breast with seasonal accompaniments. Their menu changes seasonally to feature the freshest ingredients available, making each dining experience unique.
Why Visit: The charming, intimate setting makes it a perfect place for couples or small gatherings. The attentive service and thoughtfully crafted menu items ensure an unforgettable dining experience.
3. The Lobster House
No trip to Cape May is complete without experiencing its legendary seafood. The Lobster House, located on the waterfront, offers a truly exceptional dining experience with stunning views and fresh, flavorful seafood.
Must Try: The Lobster Roll, one of the best in the area, and their famous seafood platters, which include an assortment of fresh fish, lobster, and shrimp. If you’re feeling adventurous, try the clam chowder, a local favorite.
Why Visit: With its picturesque views of the harbor and the fresh catch of the day, The Lobster House provides an authentic seafood experience. Whether you’re dining inside or enjoying the outdoor seating, you’ll be treated to both exceptional food and beautiful surroundings.
4. The Court House Deli
For a more casual and budget-friendly option, The Court House Deli is the go-to spot for delicious sandwiches, bagels, and breakfast treats. This family-owned deli has been serving the community for years and is beloved for its quality food and welcoming atmosphere.
Must Try: The classic turkey sandwich with cranberry sauce or the bacon, egg, and cheese on a fresh bagel. Their homemade soups and salads are also popular for those looking for a lighter, healthier option.
Why Visit: Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty sandwich or a quick breakfast bite, The Court House Deli is a local gem that offers a casual, friendly vibe. It’s perfect for grabbing a meal to-go or enjoying a laid-back lunch with friends.
5. Tisha’s Fine Dining
Tisha’s Fine Dining is an elegant restaurant known for its eclectic menu and artful presentation. Located in Cape May, just a short drive from Cape May Court House, Tisha’s offers a refined dining experience with a menu that combines both local ingredients and international influences.
Must Try: The Rack of Lamb or the Pan-Seared Tuna. Tisha’s is also known for their craft cocktails and dessert offerings, like the decadent chocolate mousse.
Why Visit: Tisha’s is perfect for those looking to indulge in a sophisticated dining experience. The intimate ambiance, combined with a menu that balances creativity and tradition, makes it a standout in the Cape May food scene.
6. The Merion Inn
The Merion Inn is one of the oldest and most iconic restaurants in Cape May. Known for its Victorian charm and exceptional seafood, this restaurant offers a beautiful dining experience with a nostalgic twist. Their attentive service and classic menu have made them a favorite for both locals and visitors.
Must Try: The Stuffed Flounder or the Classic Lobster Newberg. For dessert, the chocolate-covered strawberries are a treat.
Why Visit: The Merion Inn offers a classic dining experience that harks back to a time of elegance and sophistication. With its beautiful Victorian setting, it’s perfect for romantic dinners or special celebrations.
7. Lou’s Seafood Market and Eatery
Lou’s Seafood Market and Eatery offers a casual and delightful way to enjoy fresh seafood. Located in Cape May Court House, Lou’s doubles as both a seafood market and a restaurant, making it a great spot to pick up fresh fish or enjoy a meal right there.
Must Try: The Crab Cakes or Fried Shrimp Basket. Their clam strips and fish tacos are also favorites among locals.
Why Visit: Whether you want to enjoy a quick bite or pick up seafood to cook at home, Lou’s offers high-quality ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere. It’s a great place to experience the fresh seafood that the Cape May area is known for.
8. The Red Store
Located in nearby Cape May Point, The Red Store is a farm-to-table restaurant that focuses on using locally sourced ingredients to create inventive dishes. With its chic decor and modern vibe, this restaurant offers an elevated dining experience with a focus on sustainability.
Must Try: The Seasonal Vegetables with Grilled Fish or the Wood-Fired Pizza. The ever-changing menu ensures there’s always something new to try, depending on the season.
Why Visit: For those who enjoy farm-to-table dining and want to experience fresh, seasonal ingredients, The Red Store is a top choice. The cozy, contemporary ambiance makes it a great spot for dinner with friends or a romantic evening out.
Conclusion
Cape May Court House may be a small town, but its food scene is rich with variety and flavor. From casual delis to fine dining establishments, there’s something for every palate. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, creative American dishes, or classic comfort food, you’ll find a top-notch restaurant to enjoy. Don’t miss the chance to explore these culinary hotspots and savor the flavors of Cape May Court House.
Sandy